Offshore Tax Haven
Bill Summaries
H.R.
3857|H.R.
3884 | H.R. 4047 | S.2050
| S. 2119 | S. 2339| S.
2498 | H.R. 4756| H.R. 4810| H.R. 4831 | H.R.
4880 | H.R. 4993| S. 2676| H.R. 5095
March
6, 2002: Rep.
Scott McInnis (R-CO) introduces H.R.
3857, Corporate Patriot Enforcement Act of 2002.
"To amend the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986 to treat nominally foreign corporations created
through inversion transactions as domestic corporations."
- Treats "inverted"
corporations as domestic companies for tax purposes in cases where:
- the former
owners of the U.S. corporation continue to hold at least 80% of
the parent immediately following the inversion.
- The parent
is traded on the U.S. stock exchange and the current owners control
at least 50% of the parent company.
- Less than
10% of the parent company's revenue comes from its new location
and the current owners control at least 50% of the parent company.
- Less than
10% of the employees are located in the new location and the current
owners control at least 50% of the parent company
March
6, 2002: Rep.
Richard Neal (D-MA) introduces H.R.
3884, Corporate Patriot Enforcement Act of 2002.
"To amend the Internal
Revenue Code of 1986 to prevent corporations from avoiding the United
States income tax by reincorporating in a foreign country."
- Treats "inverted"
corporations as domestic companies for tax purposes in cases where:
- the former
owners of the U.S. corporation continue to hold at least 80% of
the parent immediately following the inversion.
- the former
owners of the U.S. corporation continue to hold at least 50% of
the parent company and the "nominally foreign corporation" lacks
substantial business activities in the foreign country in which
it was created and organized compared to the total activities
of the "expanded affiliated group" and the stock is publicly traded
(Also introduced
on March 11 by Rep.
Jim Maloney as H.R. 3922, Saving America's Job Act of 2002)
March
20, 2002: Rep.
Armory Houghton Jr. (R-NY) introduces H.R.
4047, International Tax Simplification and Fairness for American
Competitiveness Act of 2002
"To amend the
Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to simplify certain rules relating to the
taxation of United States businesses operating abroad, and for other purposes"
1. Revises provisions
concerning treatment of controlled foreign corporations, including:
(1) expanding the de minimis rule; (2) excluding from the definition
of "foreign base company oil related income" the pipeline
transportation of oil or gas within such foreign country; (3) repealing
rules applicable to foreign personal holding companies and foreign investment
companies; and (4) amending the definition of foreign personal holding
company income to include income from certain personal services contracts
and sale of such contracts.
2. Sets forth provisions
concerning foreign tax credit, including: (1) extending the period in
which excess foreign taxes may be carried; (2) defining overall domestic
loss and setting forth provisions for determining taxable income for
any taxpayer sustaining such a loss; (3) issuing special rules relating
to financial services income; (4) dictating rules for the treatment
of dividends from certain corporations and extending the look-through
treatment for such corporations; (5) extending the carry forward period
for foreign tax credits; (6) repealing the limitation of such credits
under the alternative minimum tax; and (7) eliminating limitation on
such credits with regard to oil or gas extraction taxes.
3. Makes other revisions, including: (1) expanding the deduction for
dividends from foreign corporations with U.S. income; (2) exempting
certain foreign corporations from uniform capitalization rules; (3)
setting forth provisions concerning airline mileage awards to certain
foreign persons; and (4) repealing the special capital gains tax on
nonresident aliens.
(a slightly modified version was introduced as H.R. 4151, Fairness, Simplification
and Competitiveness for American Business Act of 2002, by Amory Houghton
(R-NY), April 10, 2002)
(another slightly modified version was introduced as H.R. 5103, International
Tax Simplification, Fairness, and Competitiveness Act of 2002, by Sander
Levin (D-MI) on July 11, 2002)
March
21, 2002: Sen.
Paul Wellstone (D-MN) introduces S.
2050.
"To amend the
Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to treat nominally foreign corporations
created through inversion transactions as domestic corporations."
The bill treats "inverted"
corporations as domestic companies for tax purposes in cases where the
former owners of the U.S. corporation continue to hold at least 50% of
the parent immediately following the inversion
April 11, 2002: Sen.
Charles Grassley(R-IA) and Sen.
Max Baucus (D-MT) introduce S.
2119 "Reversing the Expatriation of Profits Offshore Act"
"To amend the
Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to provide for the tax treatment of inverted
corporate entities and of transactions with such entities, and for other
purposes."
This bill:
- Sets forth the
following conditions in which a foreign incorporated entity shall be
treated as an inverted domestic corporation for purposes of taxation:
- if such an
entity acquires substantially all properties held by a domestic
corporation or substantially all of the properties constituting
a trade or business of a domestic partnership;
- at least 80
percent of the stock (by vote or value) is held by former shareholders
(or partners, in the case of a partnership) of the domestic corporation
or partnership (with certain exceptions); and
- if the "expanded
affiliated group" lacks substantial business activities in its country
of origin compared to its total activities.
- Sets specific rules
covering "inversion gains" of certain "acquired entities" and party
transactions of such entities not covered by the above provisions, including:
- that taxable
income of "inversion gains" of such entities cannot be offset;
- that tax credits
shall not be permitted to be used against tax on "inversion gains"
of such entities; and
- that such
entities submit to the Secretary of the Treasury an annual prefiling,
advance pricing, or other agreement specified by the Secretary.
- Establishes penalties
for failure to make such agreements. Modifies limitation on interest
deduction for such entities.
- Invalidates certain
transfers of liabilities deemed to be aimed at avoiding the Act. Increases
scope under which the Secretary may act to modify reinsurance agreements
to take account of the amount of taxable income of each party. Defines
"acquired entities, "inversion gain," and "expanded affiliated group."
* Approved by Senate Finance Committee 6/18/02
April 26, 2002: Sen.
John Kerry (D-MA) introduces S.
2339, Tax Haven and Abusive Tax Shelter Reform Act of 2002.
"To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to curb tax
abuses by disallowing tax benefits claimed to arise from transactions
without substantial economic substance, to curb tax abuses involving identifies
tax havens, and for other purposes."
- Doubles the penalty for certain tax accuracy related underpayments.
- Creates a new penalty for not including tax shelter information with a return.
- Requires the registration of certain tax shelters without corporate participants.
- Penalizes those who promote certain tax avoidance schemes by forcing them to pay back the gains from the schemes.
- Modifies provisions concerning penalties for aiding and abetting understatement of tax liability, including adding provisions directed specifically at individuals who advise, represent, or procure certain tax shelters failing to meet legal requirements.
- Revises provisions concerning the failure to maintain lists of investors in potentially abusive tax shelters to set the penalty for certain violations at 50 percent of gross proceeds.
- Requires Americans transferring money or property to a tax haven or to a resident of a tax haven to furnish information with respect to the transfer. Permits exceptions. Imposes a financial penalty where an individual fails to provide the information requested by the Secretary.
- Reduces certain specified tax benefits with respect to income from identified tax havens.
- Imposes a financial penalty of $5,000, in addition to any other penalty imposed by law, for failing to keep records or file a required report with respect to any foreign financial agency transaction.
May 9, 2002: Sen.
Max Baucus (D-MT) introduces S.
2498
"A bill to amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to require adequate
disclosure of transactions which have a potential for tax avoidance or
evasion, and for other purposes"
This bill:
- Establishses a
civil penalty for failing to report information "reportable transactions"
having a potential for tax avoidance or evasion.
- Increases civil
penalty for making reportable transaction income tax understatements.
- Weakens confidentiality
rights of tax communications when a tax shelter is involved.
- Modifies the monetary
penalty and revises provisions for failing to register a tax shelter
with the Secretary of the Treasury.
- Increases the civil
penalty for understatement of a taxpayer's liability by an income tax
preparer.
- Establishes a fine
a frivolous tax return..
- Imposes a fine
on taxpayer representatives who are disreputable or incompetent, who
violate certain regulations or who mislead with intent to defraud.
-
Permits the Secretary
to impose a civil penalty on firms of such representatives that knew
or reasonably should have known of such conduct.
- Modifies fine for
making fraudulent statements on certain topics involving promotion of
abusive tax shelters.
* Approved by Senate
Finance Committee 6/18/02
May
16, 2002: Rep.
Nancy Johnson (R-CT) introduces H.R.
4756 "The Uncle Sam Wants You Act of 2002";
"A bill to amend
the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to impose a moratorium on the ability
of United States corporations to avoid the United States income tax by
reincorporating in a foreign country."
The bill would make
sure that companies created and organized in the United States are considered
domestic companies for tax purposes when all they do is file some paperwork
in an off-shore tax haven.
May 22, 2002: Rep.
Sam Johnson (R-TX) introduces H.R.
4810.
"To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to apply the look-thru
rules for purposes of the foreign tax credit limitation to dividends from
foreign corporations not controlled by a domestic corporation."
Amends the Internal Revenue Code to revise the application of look-thru rules to dividends from noncontrolled section 902 corporations.
May
23, 2002: Rep.
Jim Turner (D-TX) introduces H.R.
4831 "Patriotic Purchasing Act of 2002"
"To prohibit
certain expatriated corporations from being eligible for the award of
Federal Contracts"
This bill states that
any corporation that nominally reincorporates offshore to cut its taxes
will be ineligible to be awarded a federal contract
June 6, 2002: Rep.
Charles Rangel (D-NY) introduces H.R.
4880
"to amend the
Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to prevent the continued use of renouncing
United States citizenship as a device for avoiding United States taxes."
This bill treats the
property of companies that reincorporate offshore as being sold for its
fair market value on the day before the move. Then the gain or loss from
that sale would be taken into account for tax purposes, essentially making
reincorporation a taxable event.
June 21, 2002: Rep.
Lloyd Doggett (D-TX) introduces
H.R. 4993 "Patriotic Purchasing Act of 2002"
"To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to prevent corporations from
exploiting tax treaties to evade taxation of United States income."
This bill prevents
corporations who reincorporate for tax avoidance purposes from benefiting
from U.S. international tax treaties that would reduce their rate of witholding
tax.
June 21, 2002: Sens.
Robert Torricelli (D-NJ) and Orrin
Hatch (R-UT) introduce
S. 2676, Foreign Tax Credit Improvement Act of 2002
"To amend the Internal Revenue Code of 1986 to allow a 10-year foreign
tax credit carry forward and to apply the look-thru rules for purposes
of the foreign tax credit limitation to dividends from foreign corporations
not controlled by a domestic corporation."
- Amends the Internal Revenue Code to allow for a ten-year foreign tax credit carryforward.
- Revises the application of look-thru rules to dividends from noncontrolled section 902 corporations
June 21, 2002: Rep.
Bill Thomas (R-CA) introduces H.R.
5095, American Competitiveness and Corporate Accountability Act
of 2002
Competitiveness Provisions
- Repeals the Subpart F Anti-Deferral Foreign Base Company Sales and Services Rules
- Reforms Interest Allocation Rules
- Reduces Foreign Tax Credit Baskets to Three
- Extends the Foreign Tax Credit Carryover Period from 5 to 10 years
- Repeals the 90% Limitation on the Use of Foreign Tax Credits for AMT Purposes
- Recharacterizes Overall Domestic Losses
- Increases Section 179 Small Business Expensing from $24,000 to $40,000 and increases eligible investment limits from $200,000 to $325,000
- Provides Look-Through Treatment for Payments Between Related Controlled Foreign Corporations
- Provides Look-Through Treatment for Sales of Partnership Interests
- Repeals the Primarily Duplicative Foreign Personal Holding Company and Foreign Investment Company Rules
- Applies Look-Through Rules to Dividends from Noncontrolled section 902 companies (10/50 companies)
- Provides Deferral for Pipeline Transportation Income
- Provides for Attribution of Stock Ownership through Partnerships to Determine Section 902 and 960 Credits
- Provides Deferral for Commodity Hedging Income for Materials Used in Manufacturing Operations
- U.S. Property not to Include Certain Assets Acquired by Dealers in Ordinary Course of Business
- Provides for Equitable Treatment of Certain Mutual Fund Dividends
- Provides an Election not to Use Average Exchange Rate for Foreign Tax Paid other than in Functional Currency
- Repeals Withholding Tax on Dividends from Certain Foreign Corporations
- U.S. Parent not have to Recalculate its Foreign Subs E&P Under "Unicap" Rules
- Repeals the ETI Rules
Inversion Provisions
- The 1.5 to 1 debt-to-asset safe harbor is eliminated.
- Related party interest expense is disallowed to the extent that the U.S. subsidiary of a foreign owned company's debt to asset ratio exceeds the foreign company's worldwide debt to asset ratio.
- Reduces allowable interest expense from 50% to 35% of adjusted taxable income.
- Reduces disallowed interest expense carryforward from infinite to 5 years.
- Delayed effective date for non-inverted companies.
- Imposes the full tax on the transfer of assets to a foreign entity
- Imposes a 20% excise tax on the value of all stock options and stock based compensation held by insiders, top executives and directors when a company inverts.
- Imposes a 3-year moratorium for transactions completed after March 20, 2002. These transactions are disregarded.
Taxpayer provisions:
- Requires that transactions (1) have a substantial non-tax business purpose and (2) involve a meaningful change (apart from Federal income tax effects) in the taxpayer's economic position
- Imposes taxpayer penalty for failure to report a "listed" transaction.
- Imposes taxpayer penalty for failure to disclose a "reportable" transaction.
- Imposes Strict liability penalties for transactions that lack economic substance
- Increases frivolous return penalty from $500 to $5,000.
- Imposes a $5,000 penalty for failure to report an interest in a foreign financial account.
- Provides that written tax shelter communications between taxpayer and accountant are not privileged.
Promoter Provisions
- Promoters and those materially involved with "reportable" or "listed" transactions must file transactions with IRS.
- Promoters and those materially involved with "reportable" or "listed" transactions must maintain a list of investors to whom the transactions were offered.
Loophole Closers
- Closes a loophole under current law that allows executives to defer taxation on executive compensation and requires executives to stand in line with other general creditors and employees if the company becomes insolvent.
- Prevents taxpayers from improperly (1) generating foreign tax credits, (2) creating immediate tax losses, and (3) converting ordinary income into deferred capital gain.
- Closes the loopholes that permit the same partnership losses from being deducted more than once.
For more detailed summary of H.R. 5095, http://waysandmeans.house.gov/fullcomm/107cong/hr5095/hr5095summary.htm
|